Is there more to life than money? It’s a question we’ve looked at a couple of times on Debating Europe; we’ve often asked whether “wellbeing” is more important than pure economic growth.

One of the strongest arguments in favour of prioritising wellbeing is that our obsession with economic growth is, over the long-term, ecologically unsustainable. Growth depends on the consumption of natural resources, which have natural limits before they are degraded or exhausted (we cannot burn the Amazon rainforest forever). Infinite growth is not possible on a planet with finite resources.

Instead of measuring GDP, perhaps we should be measuring the “happiness” of our societies, and maybe happiness is not always dependent on having more and more stuff. Advocates of wellbeing argue it might be possible to scale back consumption (possibly even degrow our economies) and still increase overall happiness.

But what IS happiness? In order to measure something, you have to quantify it. There are various indexes purporting to measure wellbeing or happiness, but are they measuring the right things?

What do our readers think? We had a comment from Stefania, who asks: “What is happiness?” and adds that, for her, it is more than just material possessions; it is “the family, the house, the community, the story of who we are and how we learn from it, the healthy nature around me”.

So, what is happiness? We put the question to Professor Jan-Emmanuel De Neve of the University of Oxford, Director of the Wellbeing Research Centre and Associate Editor of the UN World Happiness Report. What would he say?

That’s such an important and difficult question to answer, especially in less than a minute. But it’s also a question that philosophers, and many others, have been dealing with (and cracking their heads over) for 2000 years, starting with Aristotle, and probably even before.

I think one general definition that most people can find themselves [agreeing with] would be that happiness and wellbeing are ‘how we are doing’ as individuals and communities, and how that makes us feel. Where the rubber really hits the road is when we go out and measure it. So, when we really have to define it more properly or accurately, then we tend to come down to the notion of ‘life satisfaction’. So, we’ll ask people on a scale of 1 to 10, who satisfied they are with their life [at the moment]. That allows people to essentially kind of define it how they want, or how they themselves percieve wellbeing, and what drives it. That gives us an answer about how they feel their life is going.

That is kind of the essence, in our minds, as economists and empirical scientists, of how to define wellbeing… Now, I would add that within wellbeing there are essentially dimensions that didn’t quite come through in Stefania’s description, which is that on the one hand there is the ‘evaluative’ aspect of wellbeing, which is how you evaluate your life, just the way we’ve just defined it. But there’s also more ‘in the moment’ aspects, ‘effective wellbeing’, asking how you how happy you are in this very moment – are you smiling, or experiencing stress or worry? And the third thing would be the ‘eudaimonic’, which Aristotle refered to as flourishing and thriving, more to do with purpose and meaning, really.

So, putting these three dimensions together – the evaluative, the effective, and the eudaimonic – then you get a good overview of how people are really doing in life.

For another perspective, we put the same comment to Deb Shapiro, a personal development coach and author of 18 books on personal development, meditation and social action, including Your Body Speaks Your Mind. What would she say?

The way she has of describing happiness is perfect, other than it’s all outside of her – it’s dependent on something or someone being there. And, as much as it’s the community, the family, yes, that’s where we find happiness – but the deeper happiness, in my experience, the real happiness is within ourselves regardless of what’s out there. Regardless of who, or what is going on in our lives, we can have a place of really deep happiness within ourselves which really comes from being very comfortable in our skin, from being at home with ourselves.

I’m not saying that inner happiness is easy to find. Due to a neurological disorder I cannot use my legs, no walking or even standing. For the past 4 years I have lived in a wheelchair and have rarely left home. This could be experienced as a tremendous hardship or limitation creating a loss of pleasure and joy. But I chose to make friends and be at peace with my circumstances, to find an inner joy. Being alive includes hardship, but our happiness needn’t be dependent on a freedom from suffering. It comes by making friends with what is.

How do you define happiness? Is there more to life than money? Let us know your thoughts and comments in the form below and we’ll take them to policymakers and experts for their reactions!

IMAGE CREDITS: (cc) Flickr – Tim Green

5 comments Post a commentcomment

What do YOU think?

  1. avatar
    EU Reform- Proactive

    Personal happiness is a state of one’s mind and can only be felt and experienced by that person and not measured by any e-gadget or institution.

    Human life is an accumulation of many things and becomes one’s personalized library for keeps.

    Since we all are reminded here to adhere to a strict pc EU concept, their DE agency & moderated debate- my state of mind undergoes some alteration, also not measure- able by any e-gadget or institution.

    To inquire about politically motivated “happiness”- one should rather ask:

    How would YOU define UNHAPPINESS- specifically- about the EU political concept, its affairs, its governance and future trajectory?

    One should not be surprised or offended by some answers- but appeal to the involved leadership to listen & try to make the EU majority happier!

    Example: 52% of the UK felt “EU unhappy”- 48% “EU happy”. As time passes & is wasted, everyone gets more & more frustrated. The happiness price tag- negative?

    What do we know about the state of mind of the other 27 members?

  2. avatar

    Happiness – emotional expression of how well you perform as the cog of the universal system and how resistant you are to the environmental hazards

  3. avatar

    Happiness is managing to remain sane under the daily grind of life and keeping your sense of humour.

  4. avatar

    Happiness is being happy !😂😉 when having reasonable living comfort, good education to develop your unique skills, a warm and caring family, and very important a good health, both mentally and physically so that one is able to safeguard his unique beautiful child soul. Money helps for a good start in life, but should never become an obsession.

  5. avatar

    Feeling a sense of joyous calm / energy and having my full focus on that is Happiness for me . It’s in the moment and will keep going and coming back .

Your email will not be published

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Notify me of new comments. You can also subscribe without commenting.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

By continuing to use this website, you consent to the use of cookies on your device as described in our Privacy Policy unless you have disabled them. You can change your cookie settings at any time but parts of our site will not function correctly without them.